Kummer’s Criterion

3 The relative class number

Definition 3.1
#

The inclusion \(\mathcal O_{K^+}\subseteq \mathcal O_K\) induces the class-group homomorphism

\[ \mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_{K^+})\longrightarrow \mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_K). \]
Theorem 3.2

For an odd prime cyclotomic field, the map

\[ \mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_{K^+})\longrightarrow \mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_K) \]

is injective.

Proof

It suffices to show that the kernel is trivial. If an ideal class maps to the trivial class, then the corresponding extended ideal is principal. By theorem 2.10, the original ideal is principal, so the original class is trivial.

Theorem 3.3

The plus class number divides the full class number:

\[ h^+(K)\mid h(K). \]
Proof

The injective class-group map identifies \(\mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_{K^+})\) with a subgroup of \(\mathrm{Cl}(()\mathcal O_K)\). Lagrange’s theorem for finite groups gives the divisibility of the corresponding cardinalities.

Definition 3.4
#

The relative class number is the natural-number quotient

\[ h^-(K)=h(K)/h^+(K). \]
Theorem 3.5

The class number factors as

\[ h(K)=h^+(K)h^-(K). \]
Proof

This is the definition of \(h^-\) together with theorem 3.3.

Theorem 3.6

Assume that a separate argument proves

\[ p\mid h^+(K)\Longrightarrow p\mid h^-(K). \]

Then

\[ p\mid h(K)\Longleftrightarrow p\mid h^-(K). \]
Proof

Rewrite \(h(K)\) as \(h^+(K)h^-(K)\) using theorem 3.5. If \(p\mid h(K)\), primality of \(p\) gives \(p\mid h^+(K)\) or \(p\mid h^-(K)\). The first alternative is converted to \(p\mid h^-(K)\) by the supplied implication. The converse is immediate because \(h^-(K)\) is a factor of \(h(K)\).