Kummer’s Criterion

2 Exact \(p\)-saturation

Definition 2.1
#

The ambient plus-side unit subgroup used for saturation is the full group \((\mathcal O_{K^+})^\times \).

Definition 2.2
#

For a subgroup \(H\) of an abelian group, \(H^p\) denotes the exact image of the \(p\)th-power map:

\[ H^p=\{ h^p:h\in H\} . \]
Definition 2.3
#

A subgroup \(H\le E\) is \(p\)-saturated in \(E\) when

\[ H\cap E^p\subseteq H^p. \]

Equivalently, every element of \(H\) that is a \(p\)th power in \(E\) is already a \(p\)th power inside \(H\).

Definition 2.4
#

An element written in the standard generators has the form

\[ (-1)^s\prod _a\varepsilon _a^{e_a}. \]

This expression is packaged with integer exponents \(s,e_a\).

Theorem 2.5

Every element of \(C^+\) admits such an integer-exponent expression.

Proof

This is induction on membership in the subgroup generated by \(-1\) and the finite family of real cyclotomic units. The proof checks the generators, closure under multiplication, inverses, and the identity element.

Assume that whenever

\[ (-1)^s\prod _a\varepsilon _a^{e_a} \]

is a \(p\)th power in the full unit group, every exponent \(e_a\) is zero modulo \(p\). Then \(C^+\) is \(p\)-saturated in the full plus-side unit group.

Proof

Take an element of \(C^+\) which is a \(p\)th power in the ambient unit group. Write it as an exponent product using theorem 2.5. The hypothesis says each \(e_a\) is divisible by \(p\). Divide the exponents by \(p\) to construct an element of \(C^+\) whose \(p\)th power is the original element.

Theorem 2.7

If \(C^+\) is \(p\)-saturated in the full plus-side unit group, then

\[ p\nmid [(\mathcal O_{K^+})^\times :C^+]. \]
Proof

The group-theoretic input says that a finite-index \(p\)-saturated subgroup has index prime to \(p\) when all ambient \(p\)-torsion already lies in the subgroup. For \(C^+\), the torsion condition follows from the description of torsion units in \(K^+\), and finite index is supplied by the cyclotomic-unit index setup.