Kummer’s Criterion

6 The Carlitz escape argument

Lemma 6.1
✓

Let \(p\) be an odd prime and \(m\) an even index with \((p-1)\nmid m\). Then \(m' := m \bmod (p-1)\) satisfies \(0 {\lt} m' {\lt} p-1\), \(m'\) is even, and \(m \equiv m' \pmod{p-1}\). In particular \(2 \le m' \le p-3\).

Proof ▶

The residue is nonzero precisely because \((p-1)\nmid m\), and it inherits parity from \(m\) since \(p-1\) is even.

An odd prime \(p\) is irregular if and only if \(p \mid \operatorname {num}(B_m/m)\) for some positive even index \(m\).

Proof ▶

If \(p\) is irregular, theorem 1.2 produces a witness \(B_{2k}\) in Kummer’s range; since \(2k \le p-3 {\lt} p\), the index is a unit modulo \(p\) and the divisibility passes to the divided numerator.

Conversely, suppose \(p\mid \operatorname {num}(B_m/m)\) with \(m\) positive and even. By theorem 2.4, necessarily \((p-1)\nmid m\). Let \(m'\) be the positive residue of lemma 6.1. The full Kummer congruence (theorem 5.3) gives \(B_m/m \equiv B_{m'}/m' \pmod p\), so \(p\mid \operatorname {num}(B_{m'}/m')\) by lemma 2.2, hence \(p \mid \operatorname {num}(B_{m'})\) by lemma 2.3. Since \(2 \le m' \le p-3\) and \(m'\) is even, this is a Bernoulli witness in Kummer’s range, and \(p\) is irregular by theorem 1.1.

For every finite set \(S\) of natural numbers there are \(M\) and a prime \(p\) such that \(M\) is even and positive, \((q-1)\mid M\) for every prime \(q \in S\), the prime \(p\) is odd, \(p\mid \operatorname {num}(B_M/M)\), and \(p \notin S\).

Proof ▶

Put \(M = C(S)\cdot 2^t\) with \(t\) chosen by corollary 3.3 so that \(|B_M/M| {\gt} 1\). By lemma 2.1 some prime \(p\) divides \(\operatorname {num}(B_M/M)\). By theorem 2.4, \((p-1)\nmid M\); in particular \(p \ne 2\). If \(p\) were in \(S\), then \((p-1)\mid C(S)\mid M\) by lemma 4.2, a contradiction; so \(p \notin S\). The divisibility \((q-1)\mid M\) for \(q \in S\) is again lemma 4.2.

For every finite set \(S\) of natural numbers there is an irregular prime \(p \notin S\).

Proof ▶

Take the prime \(p\) and the index \(M\) of theorem 6.3. Then \(p\) is irregular by theorem 6.2 and \(p \notin S\).

Theorem 6.5
✓

There are infinitely many irregular primes.

Proof ▶

By theorem 6.4 no finite set contains all irregular primes, so the set is infinite by lemma 1.3.

1

L. Carlitz, Note on irregular primes, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 5 (1954), 329–331.

2

K. Ireland and M. Rosen, A Classical Introduction to Modern Number Theory, 2nd ed., Graduate Texts in Mathematics 84, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1990.

3

K. L. Jensen, Om talteoretiske Egenskaber ved de Bernoulliske Tal, Nyt Tidsskrift for Matematik 26 (1915), 73–83.

4

E. E. Kummer, Allgemeiner Beweis des Fermatschen Satzes, daSS die Gleichung \(x^\lambda + y^\lambda = z^\lambda \) durch ganze Zahlen unlösbar ist, für alle diejenigen Potenz-Exponenten \(\lambda \), welche ungerade Primzahlen sind und in den Zählern der ersten \((\lambda -3)/2\) Bernoullischen Zahlen als Factoren nicht vorkommen, J. Reine Angew. Math. 40 (1850), 130–138.

5

W. Sinnott, On the Stickelberger ideal and the circular units of a cyclotomic field, Ann. of Math. (2) 108 (1978), 107–134.

6

L. C. Washington, Introduction to Cyclotomic Fields, 2nd ed., Graduate Texts in Mathematics 83, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1997.